How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Moderator: Maxim_TS


osity
User
Posts: 491
Joined: 05.12.15
Reputation: 4 / (44)

How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby osity » 20.09.17, 16:31

WD 2.5" 2 platter drive-FBlite
Seems like a simple question, but I'm looking for detail. What symptoms would I see if the bottom platter was inserted upside down? Would I still be able to access SA?

User avatar
Blizzard
New user
Posts: 96
Joined: 29.06.16
Reputation: 5 / (47)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby Blizzard » 20.09.17, 18:09

Even if we ignore that 0 becomes 1 and 1 becomes 0... If you think about it, wouldn't an "upside down" platter be spinning backwards? :)


osity
User
Posts: 491
Joined: 05.12.15
Reputation: 4 / (44)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby osity » 20.09.17, 21:41

Blizzard, Yes it would.
I'm in this situation where the bottom platter may be upside down but interestingly enough I'm able to get SA SPT and to copy 1 and copy 2 of the SA. The drive actually stays spinning but only if i use headmap 1111.
I think it's ignoring the other platter completely and thinking its a one platter drive. Im not getting full ID though..

Trying to figure out if the platter is in fact upside down.
Last edited by osity on 20.09.17, 21:52, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Blizzard
New user
Posts: 96
Joined: 29.06.16
Reputation: 5 / (47)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby Blizzard » 20.09.17, 21:47

What model HDD? What is the head map? Head 1 is probably the same platter as head 0 so I think you might just have a bad head 0. What makes you think someone flipped the platter?


osity
User
Posts: 491
Joined: 05.12.15
Reputation: 4 / (44)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby osity » 20.09.17, 21:57

WD10JMVW
Head map is 0123.
I think the platters may have been flipped because I removed them a few times ;)
Originally the drive was stable without modifying headmap and now its not unless i modify it to 1111.
I haven't ruled out platter alignment but I took precautions for that. It could just be heads.

User avatar
DataMedics
Advanced user
Posts: 619
Joined: 14.12.15
Reputation: 18 / (177)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby DataMedics » 21.09.17, 01:15

osity wrote:Source of the post Originally the drive was stable without modifying headmap and now its not unless i modify it to 1111.
I haven't ruled out platter alignment but I took precautions for that. It could just be heads.


So why the heck did you remove the platters? I really hope this isn't a client's drive you're messing around with.


osity
User
Posts: 491
Joined: 05.12.15
Reputation: 4 / (44)

Re: How would I know if one of my platters was upside down

Postby osity » 21.09.17, 02:51

Of course it's a clients Drive. This is a professional environment not HDDguru.com :) One head was reading but others were not despite being changed three times. Platters were completely contaminated with splatters and smear residue from another lab in San Francisco that deemed it unrecoverable. I've already recovered some files from this 'unrecoverable drive' despite it's terrible condition. Any input is appreciated!

I'd also like to know how you expect to find scratches on platters zero and one without removing platters. Bore Cameras don't seem to do a good job.


Return to “WD Marvell”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests